Home Page Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Insurance Life Insurance Request a Quote

Report a Claim


Handling your claim quickly and fairly is our priority. If you are reporting a claim during regular business hours, please call our office at 419-636-3134, or toll free at 877-636-3134.

If it is necessary to report a claim after business hours or on weekends, you may wish to report the claim directlly to the company at one of the numbers listed below.
Grange   24 hours claims reporting: 800-445-3030
Auto glass claims: 800-951-9734
Motorists   Claim reporting: 800-876-3298
Report your claim online
Auto Owners   Emergency After Hours Claims: 888-ClaimAO (1-888-252-4626)
(Available from 4:30pm to 8:00am, M-F and 24 hours a day weekends and holidays.)
Ohio Mutual   24 hour claims reporting: 888-895-7725
Mennonite Mutual   Claims reporting: 800-678-6885, ext. 120
Tuscarora Wayne   Report claims to our office at 419-636-3134 or 877-636-3134
Progressive   Claim reporting: 800-272-4499
Report your claim online
Hagerty   Claim reporting: 800-922-4050, option #5
Report your claim online
Wayne Mutual   Emergency claim reporting: 800-222-3873 x310
Home Page Our Products Our Carriers File A Claim Make A Payment FAQs Videos Glossary